Study about bullying
My literature research also brought me to this study about bullying:
https://www.pistes.uqam.ca/v7n3/articles/v7n3a2en.htm
There are many interesting findings in this study. I am most interested in these two:
- Men are bullied by their superiors exclusively and women not only from above but from all directions, including colleagues and even those below her in hierarchy. This is a strong evidence that women´s position in hierarchy is differently perceived than for men.
- Bullying seems to be related to and supported by performance-based payment. This corresponds to my experience with this tool of HR management. It is a powerful tool, exercising strong influence on people´s thinking and decisions, but it is like magic: powerful, but not completely controllable. I believe that performance- or object-oriented payment/ management destroys the team spirit. Maybe, one should treat teams as a unit and define team objectives, but I am not completely sure that this would work well. I remember from sports where the ambitious team bullied weaker team members. When they get rid of low performers, the team performance is higher. So, maybe management by numbers is a Pandora box that one should not open at all.
https://www.pistes.uqam.ca/v7n3/articles/v7n3a2en.htm
There are many interesting findings in this study. I am most interested in these two:
- Men are bullied by their superiors exclusively and women not only from above but from all directions, including colleagues and even those below her in hierarchy. This is a strong evidence that women´s position in hierarchy is differently perceived than for men.
- Bullying seems to be related to and supported by performance-based payment. This corresponds to my experience with this tool of HR management. It is a powerful tool, exercising strong influence on people´s thinking and decisions, but it is like magic: powerful, but not completely controllable. I believe that performance- or object-oriented payment/ management destroys the team spirit. Maybe, one should treat teams as a unit and define team objectives, but I am not completely sure that this would work well. I remember from sports where the ambitious team bullied weaker team members. When they get rid of low performers, the team performance is higher. So, maybe management by numbers is a Pandora box that one should not open at all.
AndreaHerrmann - 4. Sep, 11:57
